
Swimming
Mac Miller's last studio album before leaving us all wondering what musical genres he could have melded if he had stuck around.

by Mykie R
September 14th, 2023
Share this Article
Have you ever come across an artist you love right at the wrong time? It can be devastating to fall in love with someone’s music only to find out they aren’t around any more. That’s pretty much sums up my relationship with Mac Miller.
I didn’t know too much about Mac until I found out he’d died and then it was all too late for me to begin building that small fortress of wonder and hope that one builds when waiting for new music from an artist you love. I actually first heard that he’d passed away when I started seeing tributes pour in. And they were from artists far and wide. It seemed that everyone had a soft spot for this unassuming dude whose musical approach was a lot like his personality. Laid back, cruisy and nothing but honest when it came to his lyrics. But it was the way he delivered them that was the real heart crunching loss.
Yeah… sigh It’s a weird bittersweet feeling knowing that someone you’ve just realised is awesome has passed away. It was the end of 2018 when he died of an overdose. There is a whole story around his departure and the dudes who sold him the gear that killed him. I like to keep it about the music but from what I understand [probs worth a read if you’re interested] they knew it wasn’t what it should have been which makes me ten degrees more sad about it all sighs again. But I’d rather have the bittersweetness than nothing at all.

I’m not sure whether it shaded my love of him or if I just sympathised with someone who struggled internally and continued to try and make sense it of through his music. But if you listen to Miller’s music enough [particularly his later stuff], there’s a real surrender to the temperature of his music and one that always kinda makes me feel as though I should be standing alone next to the oil drum fire at a party while everyone else is mingling….and to be entirely happy about it.
I think it’s because there’s an intimacy to Mac Millers later music. Like it’s a conversation between you and him and he’s telling you stories of what he’s been through and that whatever you’re going through is cool too. Acceptance out of wanting to be accepted? or simply someone who’s found their peace with who they are and are happy to share that space with anyone who may have found themselves on the same path.
Maybe the real power of Millers work is that even though he didn’t do things that weren’t exactly healthy for himself [ahem], he’s honest enough to admit that there’s a better way just down the road. Via his super chill musicality that belongs on the back seat of the bus, he invites you to come with him. I know there’s a part of me that identifies…with the struggle. With the pain. With the constant drive to try and do better even though sometimes I don’t. I think that’s why we resonate with particular artists right? Because the story they weave throughout their music hits a chord with the listener that says ‘I get you’.
So partner his back of the bus nature with the shadow of his death and I found myself wanting to hear more but kinda not wanting it to be awesome because the better the music was, the more of a tragedy it would be….and then he posthumously wins best Rap album for ‘Swimming’, the album he was supposed to begin touring with before he died. The best music he’s ever produced. Period.
The story just gets better and worse all at the same time because the album he had just released was not only the best music he had ever produced, for me, it was one of the best Hip Hop albums of the century. keeps sighing…*even shakes head*.
I smashed ‘Swimming’. Like inside and out, I played this thing to death. It meanders in and out of a groove that never becomes too much. It’s right in the pocket of intelligently honest storytelling, easy kick back grooves and a vocal track that always seems to be half a second late for the party…intentionally.
After I’d worn the wheels of ‘Swimming’ out as far as they’d go, my posthumous crate diving expedition of Mac’s work opened up a clear differentiation between the early, raw work of ‘Blue Slide Park’ [2011] & ‘Watching Movies with the Sound Off’ [2013] and the later work of ‘The Divine Feminine’ [2016] and ‘Swimming’ [2018]. And as per the human condition, we all have differing views on people we love, especially musically, but for me there was an album that sits in between these called ‘GO:OD AM’ [2015] that showed his transition. A softening into his voice that afforded his music this feeling of getting to hold his hand while he narrates a story as opposed to the separation that happens when you feel like someone is performing. It’s like everything slowed down. The energy of these later albums in general feel easier, more connected and more heartfelt.
This probably kills me more considering he was only 26 when he passed. I would love to have seen what he’d have produced as he grew but its not the first or last time we’ll say this about an artist.
There are differing opinions of him, but over time, a lot of those negative opinions have died down and what remains is really the only thing that matters. I also know that people like Mac can be divisive. I know I’ve spoken reflectively about him in a pretty affectionate light, but the reality is that I can only take my opinion of him from his music and what others have said of him [as well the Youtube encyclopaedia of everything]. And really…regardless of what he was like as a human, I choose to love him for his music and his artist persona. From what I’ve read [and I’m sure bigger Mac Miller fans could out fact me here], he was somewhat of a perfectionist who kept a tight circle of jazz fusion influenced artists like Thundercat, Vince Staples & Kendrick. Thats a pretty effective peer group.
But like most people with enough demons to have to do something to quell them on occasion, that perfectionist in him could often have him spending too many hours in his head. Again, just something I think a lot of us can identify with. With a career that spanned nearly a decade, you can see the evolution in his albums, but it’s his voice that is his most effective tool. It’s unmistakable and will never be able to be replicated. Ever.
So, as I was simply ready to put a nice little bow around the Mac Miller albums box in my head after his death, a few years later I was scrolling through some new releases and who the fuck pops up? Like seriously, WTF?…*calls from the office to my wife in the lounge room…”BABY!!! Guess what!!!!* And the ‘guess what’ was an album called ‘Circles’. A sister album apparently always intended to be released along with Swimming but obviously never had the chance to see the light of day. Produced by the super talented Jon Brion. For those not familiar with Brion, he’s quite a big behind the scenes guy. Produced a lot of music for artists such as Fiona Apple, Elliott Smith, The Eels, Kanye, Crystal Method, but is probably most widely known for his work creating soundtracks. At least that’s where I know him most from.

Jon produced Swimming for Mac in 2018, which make a lot of sense in hindsight considering Brion’s cinematic experience and Miller’s embracing of a more heartfelt, less aggressive approach, and after Mac’s death in 2018, put together the remnants of what they had been working on as Mac’s final studio album just over a year after his death. And it’s possibly one of the most reflective and melancholy albums I’ve ever heard. Perfect Miller. If you get a chance, the first track ‘Circles’ I think sums up his ability to self analyse and continue to turn it into the most simple, heartfelt piece of music. In my opinion, it’s definitely an album that smacks of both Miller & Brion’s collaboration, but moreover it feels as though Brion was paying tribute to Mac in the best way possible. In a way that we all get to enjoy.
I think Mac Miller is the kind of artist I could write ten times more about and still not scratch the surface. His music, his life. But at the end of the day, what’s really the most important part is how the music makes us feel. And for me, Mac Miller’s music is something else. To come across that kind of influence and then remember that they’re not around anymore can bring back that feeling of melancholy. But like most people in this world, I’ve experienced enough death in this life to know that we all need that feeling just as much as the good ones, or the angry ones…or the nothing ones.
Melancholy is so important to keep close to our hearts. It feels as though it’s our ability to experience sadness in a positive way. I often get this way when I listen to Jeff Buckley, but I’ll admit that unlike Jeff, Mac keeps me feeling like there’s always a light at the end of the tunnel. And I often feel like I’m in tunnel.
So, in the spirit of living in a world of uncertainty, may I suggest finding a copy of ’Swimming’ and throwing it on to lift your spirits in a way that maybe you’re not used to. If you’re inclined to steer the mood the other way, throw on circles. Either way, you should come out the end of both albums feeling like you might just want to flip the album and give it another spin.
M ///


